Two items this week have prompted me to think again about Gregory P. Stone’s distinction between play and display (American Sports: Play and Dis-Play, in Eric Larrabee and Rolf Meyersohn (eds.), Mass Leisure. Glencoe, Ill.: Free Press, 1958. See too his discussion of wrestling, 1971).
The ABC reported that “Western Bulldogs coach Rodney Eade says he would not be surprised if AFL opponents were eavesdropping on his match-day coaching instructions.” The report notes that “While other clubs use more secure digital communications system that are encrypted, the Bulldogs have a cheaper analogue system, which Eade said needed upgrading.” Rodney Eade is quoted on the subject of technological vulnerability:
You know that it goes on, so I think as a club and organisation we’ve got to now work ways that it can’t be listened into. On grand final day, you’d hate to think it would cost you a game when a move was predicated and actually didn’t give you the advantage you hoped.
In a second report, the ABC noted that “New Zealand-born photographer Scott Barbour has been banned by the New Zealand Rugby Union (NZRU) from covering the All Blacks’ Bledisloe Cup build-up after he deliberately exposed the team’s game plan.” His image “of coach Graham Henry holding the team’s tactical move was reproduced in Australian media outlets.” The NZ Herald analysed the moves in detail.
The ABC report suggests that “All Blacks assistant coach Steve Hansen described Barbour’s actions as a “breach of trust”, saying he broke an “unwritten rule” by photographing the blueprint displaying moves from lineouts and scrums.” A TVNZ post quotes Steve Hanson: “With any breach of trust you take your time and talk about it. It’s not the end of the world. We will deal with that in our own way.”
Reading both these reports I wondered how these experiences help us clarify:
- What constitutes fair play?
- What role should (any) technology play in sport?
- How skilful can we be in he art of off-field disclosure?
- What role on-field deception should play?
- Will the call for fairness off the field be reciprocated on the field of play?
Listening to Podcasts on a Mobile Phone
Photographing the Photographer
The final session of Day One was introduced by Ken Norris. James Fantasia (Director of Football), Rodney Eade (Head Coach) and Bill Davoren (Head, Physical Conditioning) presented The Team Behind a High Performing Sport: A Case Study.
James Fantasia introduced the talk. He shared a video of a week behind the scenes with the Bulldogs club in Round 15 week v Collingwood (one point loss 110-111). Channel 7 filmed the week’s preparation. James provided some historical background to the Bulldogs (Founded 1877, entered the VFL in 1925). he noted the development of a Learning Centre at the club (a $30 million faciliity). The club has 20 full-time personnel and 55 part-time staff. There are seven key areas (administration, coaching, physical conditioning, development, medical services, recruiting, football operations and logistics).
James presented an organisational plan but acknowledged that the club is a flat line organisation. He noted the importance of the club’s business values. The Bulldogs are a process driven club keen to preserve intellectual property. The club uses the Leading Teams approach. Bulldogs have adapted this approach. James discussed role clarity at the club and noted that everyone is clear about their responsibilities.
James concluded his talk with some characteristics of the culture at the club:
- Education priorities
- Attention paid to the recruitment of staff
- Standards on and off the field
- Honest and open communication including peer assessment
Rodney Eade discussed the Coaching Department at the club and explored the environment the club wants to create. There are 45 players and 20 staff. The key functions of the Coaching Department are: game plan; skills; training planning; analysis; game review; match day preparation; season, weekly and daily planning; individual sessions. Rodney discussed four key points:
- Role of the Head Coach
- Openness to knowledge sharing
- Clarity of goals (and process delivers goals)
Rodney noted the commitment to a continuous improvement environment. Creative thinking is encouraged in high challenge environments. Emphasis is placed on an enjoyable daily training environment. He was very clear about the superordinate importance of the team.
Bill Davron discussed his 12 months of learning in AFL. A year ago he jumped at the opportunity to take up his role at the club.He shared his admiration for the game and the players in it. he gave an example of Preliminary Final intensity. In this game one athlete ran 19.5kms, 7kms of this at high intensity. The player had 350 efforts and 290 maximum accelerations.
Bill underscored the demand to make hard decisions quickly in AFL and used his own experience of modulating training for 45 players’ loads. What pathway should be developed for each player? Bill emphasised the importance of links he had developed with Victoria University to develop his approach at the club.