A letter to the Secret Soccer Analyst

A training session

Dear Secret Soccer Analyst

I have four apologies to make to you.

First, I am sorry I missed your post when you first published it. Fortunately, Richard Whittall, Rob Carroll and Darrell Cobner alerted me to your story.

When I last looked Richard’s tweet had received 918 likes and 255 retweets. Martin Bucheit’s tweet about your post has 19 likes.

Your open sharing has touched many people. I am late to the party but am touched too. Profoundly so.

A picture of a videographer at a training session.

 I have been involved in the analysis of performance since the late 1970s.

In the 1990s, I worked as a performance analyst in rugby union. For most of the decade, I had intense work periods that during competition and overseas tours extended to 18 hour days … week after week.

It was an analogue video world. I was fortunate to have access to host broadcast videos and captured my own game video with the help of colleagues. We thought we had hit the jackpot with S-VHS format.

I have a second apology to make.

When I started the Centre for Notational Analysis in Cardiff in 1991, I hoped to create a career path for young people interested in performance analysis. We were at the start of a movement that has positioned you to feel the way you do.

I am staggered by the creativity of people like yourself. The world you occupy is a quantum shift from the occupational culture of the 1990s.

We do share the same vision though … to provide an invisible service to coaches that records, analyses and potentially transforms performance.

Filming training

My third apology is that despite my advocacy for performance analysis as a service, I have had limited success in persuading clubs and sporting organisations that our work should be valued rather than priced.

Young people are still inducted into performance analysis as unpaid interns or lowly paid analysts. We are encouraged to believe that the status of being connected with a club or team ‘compensates’ for zero or low wages.

Some learning organisations are pro-actice and make every effort to support their analysts financially and through continuing learning opportunities.

Our dilemma is that we have so many people wanting to be analysts and often have the experiences you have.

My fourth apology is to lament that I have not been able to gain acceptance for two fundamental questions:

What is so important we have to share it?

Can less be more?

At the heart of this conversation is a profound debate about frequent augmented information. The availability of hardware and software has led to a surfeit of options for each analyst.

It has created an insatiability that we as a profession must address. We either need more people or automation to help us or we use the two questions above and add two more:

What has changed in performance in training and competition?

How might feedforward transform our practice?

Much of my time now is spent in exhorting our community of practice to share experiences openly. Your post is a very important marker in our conversation about practice and reminded me of that quote in Shadowlands

We read to know we are not alone.

Now that you have shared your thoughts, I hope you realise that you have a world of friends who are just a phone call or email away.

I hope too you will accept my apologies.

Keith

Photo Credits

Training day in 38C heat (Keith Lyons, CC BY 4.0)

A game of rugby union in 1907

A picture of the Stade Francais rugby union team. 1903.

Thanks to Darrell Cobner, I have another discovery to share.

A photograph of Maurice Martin.Darrell suggested I look at Frederic Humbert’s blog, Rugby Pioneers. (Simon Eaves and Paul Worsfold also link to Frederic’s post in their 2014 review of notational analysis for rugby football.)

In 2010, Frederic shared the story of Maurice Martin and Fernand Bidault’s visit to Bordeaux on 24 March 1907 to record the French Rugby Union Championship final.

Their hand notation records “la marche du ballon a travers les deux camps”. This record of their notation includes a photograph of their observation point on the top of the grandstand at the Stade Sainte-Germaine at Le Bouscat.

A photograph of the hand notation of the 1907 rugby union final.

There were 12,000 spectators at the game so the vantage point would have been particularly helpful in their comprehensive “schema chronometre”.  The notation is recorded with the time of day: kick off 3pm, end of first half 3.43 pm; second half starts 4pm and ends at 4.47pm.

The home team, SBUC, won the game by 14 points to 3 (4 tries to 1). It was 6 points to 3 at half time (2 tries to 1). The SBUC tries were scored by Maurice Leuvielle, Jacques Dufourcq, Marc Giacardy, and Pascal Laporte. Henri Martin converted one of these tries. The Stade Francais try was scored by Charles Vareilles.

I was fascinated to discover this notation. Eighty-four years later, I was perched in the top of the old Cardiff Arms Park using hand notation to record the flow of an international game. I did have the advantage of a stopwatch and a roof on a rainy day.

Photo Credit

Maurice Martin (Wikipedia)

Stade Fracais 1903 (Frederic Humbert)

Exploring our performance analysis and sport analytics history

A photograph of one of the 47 shots at goal in the West Europe v Central Europe football game played on 20 june 1937.

Yesterday, I was re-reading Ben Alamar and Vijay Mehrotra’s 2011 discussion of the rapidly evolving world of sports analytics (Part 1).

They have a reference to G R Lindsey’s 1959 paper proposing an operational analysis approach to baseball.

By delightful serendipity, Simon Gleave was tweeting at the same time with news of Jurryt van de Vooren’s discovery of some 1937 association football data.

I do not have any earlier record of notating goal scoring in association football but Simon’s connection with Jurryt has added another piece in our jigsaw about the origins of performance analysis and sport analytics.

We have a record of 47 shots (23 first half, 24 second half) from the game played between West Europe (28 shots) and Central Europe (19 shots).

Ferenc Sas scored two of Central Europe’s goals “with assists from György Sárosi and Italy’s Silvio Piola“. (All three of them played a year later in the World Cup Final.)

A list of the 47 shots at goal in the West europe v Central Europe football game, 20 june 1937.

Another corner piece comes from 24 September 1898. This appears to be the oldest football clip in existence. The film is included in a Daily Mail article from 2014. The teams involved were Blackburn Rovers and West Bromwich Albion.

I am hopeful that our crowdsourcing will produce even more genealogy connections. My earliest baseball discovery is from 1910 and Hugh Fullerton’s account of the inside game.

Our timeline in association football now has some important landmarks:

24 September 1898

20 June 1937

… and 18 March 1950 (Charles Reep at Swindon Town v Bristol Rovers).

Photo Credits

Both pictures shared here are from Jurryt’s 17 December 2016 blog post Werden de eerste voetbalstatistieken al in 1937 gemaakt?